Journal: Scientific Reports
Article Title: Multilevel structure–activity profiling reveals multiple green tea compound families that each modulate ubiquitin-activating enzyme and ubiquitination by a distinct mechanism
doi: 10.1038/s41598-019-48888-6
Figure Lengend Snippet: Catechin gallates, alkyl gallates, and myricetin reduce cell viability in a manner protected by overexpression of Uba1 or ubiquitin in cells and EGCG inhibits global cellular ubiquitination. ( a ) Dose–response for effects on HEK 293 cell survival after 24-h treatment with each compound relative to parallel untreated controls by the Alamar Blue (resazurin) assay. Data represent mean ± SD for 4–6 independent experiments (as indicated along with IC 50 values for each case in Table ), plotted both linearly and semi-logarithmically (inset), with a DMSO concentration of 2% in all cases. ( b ) Overexpression of Uba1 or ubiquitin reduces sensitivity of cells to the cytostatic/cytotoxic effects of the compounds that also have in vitro activity against PCNA ubiquitination and Uba1~ubiquitin thioester formation (Figs and ) but not those without activity (Figs and ). Data represent mean and SD for % cell survival relative to parallel controls (DMSO alone) for three independent experiments, with a DMSO concentration of 2% in all cases. Higher survival values following compound treatment between Uba1- or ubiquitin-overexpressing HEK 293 cells compared to the corresponding empty vector-transfected control cells after 24-h compound treatment are indicated with an asterisk ( p < 0.003 in all cases by unpaired two-tailed Student’s t -tests). Treatment concentrations were at the IC 50 values initially calculated for each compound shown in Table from the data in ( a ), as well as 1 μM and 2 μM for puromycin—denoted as “Puro (1)” and “Puro (2),” respectively—to evaluate effects of an unrelated cytotoxic agent. Note: EC, Cat, Myr, and DM all exhibited only very weak activity at 500 μM in the cell viability experiments in ( a ), and we were not able to test over high enough concentration range for proper determination of their IC 50 values. However, of these four compounds, we chose to still examine whether Uba1 and/or ubiquitin overexpression affected cell survival for Myr at 3 mM and DM at 650 μM (corresponding to their crudely guesstimated IC 50 values), respectively, because Myr and DM had in vitro activity (Figs and ), whereas EC and Cat did not (Figs and ). Western blots of lysates from cells transfected with empty vector control, FLAG-ubiquitin-expressing, or FLAG-Uba1-expressing vector probed with anti-FLAG antibody, then stripped and probed with an anti-DNA polymerase δ catalytic subunit antibody as a loading control. The graph at right shows that Uba1 or ubiquitin overexpression by themselves had no effect on cell number in the parallel control cells in DMSO alone (mean and SD for three independent experiments), expressed as resorufin product signal in arbitrary fluorescence units (AFU) resulting from the metabolic reduction of resazurin in the assay. OE = overexpression. ( c ) Representative Western blot showing inhibition of global ubiquitination by EGCG in HEK 293 cells. Cells were treated with EGCG at 250 μM and 500 μM (with DMSO alone as control and a DMSO concentration of 1% in all cases) for 30 min, then MG132 was added to 50 μM, and cells were incubated for another 30 min, for a total EGCG treatment time of 1 h. Equivalent loadings of total protein from whole-cell lysates were subjected to Western blot analysis with anti-ubiquitin antibody and then with anti-β-tubulin antibody as a housekeeping protein loading control.
Article Snippet: His-tagged human Uba1 in the pET3a bacterial expression vector (Addgene Cat#63571) was expressed in the E . coli strain BL21(DE3) and purified with Ni-NTA agarose beads (Macherey-Nagel).
Techniques: Over Expression, Resazurin Assay, Concentration Assay, In Vitro, Activity Assay, Plasmid Preparation, Transfection, Two Tailed Test, Western Blot, Expressing, Fluorescence, Inhibition, Incubation